This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.
← Diamond grading standards

Diamond Grading Labs Compared: GIA, GCAL, IGI and More

Every lab uses the same words (D colour, VS2, Excellent) but not the same standard. A G VS1 from one lab can look like an H VS2 from another, and the price reflects it. Here's who the main labs are, what each is known for, and which report we'd look for on a natural or a lab-grown diamond.

The labs at a glance

LabWhat to knowLab-grown
GIAFounded in 1931, a nonprofit based in Carlsbad, California. The reference for colour and clarity grading worldwide. Gives a cut grade to round diamonds only.Since October 2025, Premium or Standard instead of 4C grades.
GCAL by SarineIndependent lab in New York, majority-owned by the diamond-technology company Sarine since 2023. Measures cut and optical performance in detail, and issues the GCAL 8X cut grade.Full grading, same 8X criteria as natural.
IGIThe largest grader by volume. Its 2024 IPO filing put its share at 33% of all grading reports and 65% of lab-grown. Since 2021 it has run grading set-ups inside some growers' factories.Full 4C grading; the most common lab-grown report.
AGSIts lab closed at the end of 2022 and GIA took over its technology. GIA now offers a supplemental AGS Ideal report that grades light performance.AGS Ideal report available through GIA.
HRD AntwerpBelgian lab focused on natural diamonds.Stopped grading loose lab-grown diamonds from 2026.
EGLRapNet, the main trading network, banned EGL reports in 2014 over inconsistent grading, and EGL International closed that year. EGL USA continues as a separate company. 

Sources: GIA, GCAL, JCK and National Jeweler, read November 2026. IGI's market share is from a study IGI commissioned for its IPO.

  • Natural

For a natural diamond: GIA

GIA's colour and clarity grades are the ones the trade prices against. The same diamond graded by a less strict lab often comes back a grade or two higher, and it trades at a discount for that reason. A GIA report removes the doubt.

If cut is your priority, a GCAL 8X report on top tells you the cut is in the top tier. What GIA triple excellent means.

"Basically, if you show an IGI graded stone to a professional, the first question he will ask himself is, "I wonder how GIA would have graded this." If you already have a GIA report, there's no doubt about it."

"GIA grades to a more strict standard than IGI, so a stone that gets F color from IGI (for example) might get G color from GIA. Since the prices are based on the grades, this is a big deal!"

  • Lab-grown

For a lab-grown diamond: GCAL for the strictest grading

Most lab-grown diamonds come with IGI reports, and GIA moved lab-grown to broad Premium and Standard descriptions in October 2025. If you want a lab-grown diamond graded in full detail, to the strictest standard, GCAL is the lab we'd look for, and GCAL 8X if cut matters most to you.

We also work with IGI-graded lab-grown diamonds. We sort through them for you, because the grade on the report doesn't always match what we see in the stone.

"For consumers looking for the strictest standards in lab grown diamond grading I recommend GCAL."

"For the record, I work with IGI, GIA, and GCAL stones. IGI stones require a lot more work on my part, because approximately 8/10 of them don't meet my quality standards, and it's a lot of labor to sort them out. I do that labor, as a service to my clients."

Why a lab report matters at all

A report is a third party's word that the diamond is what the seller says it is. Without one, you're relying on the seller's own grading, and the price is set by the grade. Ask for the report of the exact stone you're buying, check that its number matches the inscription on the girdle, and look it up on the lab's website.

Then look at the diamond. Two stones with the same grades from the same lab can still look different, which is why we show you stones side by side, in person by appointment or by video call.

"It's a verification from an independent third party that the grades of the diamond are what the seller says they are. Otherwise, what's to stop the seller from "exaggerating" a bit and (over)charging you accordingly."

Grading lab questions

Which diamond grading lab is the best?

For colour and clarity on a natural diamond, GIA is the reference. For the most detailed cut grading, on natural or lab-grown, GCAL and its 8X grade set the strictest standard. Which report is best depends on the diamond and on what matters most to you.

Is IGI as good as GIA?

Not for natural diamonds, in our experience: IGI tends to grade colour and clarity more generously, and IGI-graded stones trade at lower prices for that reason. IGI is the most common lab for lab-grown diamonds, and good IGI stones exist, but they need careful sorting.

Does AGS still grade diamonds?

The AGS lab closed at the end of 2022 and GIA took over its technology. GIA now issues a supplemental AGS Ideal report that grades light performance.

Which lab should grade a lab-grown diamond?

GCAL if you want detailed grading to the strictest standard. GIA describes lab-grown diamonds only as Premium or Standard since October 2025, and IGI grades the largest share of lab-grown diamonds.

More on diamond grading standards

Each standard measures something different. Read the next guide, or start with the Four C's.

All grading standards

GCAL 8X, GIA Excellent, AGS Ideal and Hearts & Arrows, side by side.

Read more

GCAL 8X

The strictest independent cut standard: eight criteria, all Excellent.

Read more

GIA triple excellent

What Excellent cut, polish and symmetry means, and where it stops.

Read more

Hearts & Arrows

A sign of precise symmetry in a round diamond, not a grade.

Read more

Inside the GCAL lab

Dan Moran tours GCAL in New York with its president, Angelo Palmieri.

Read more

Looking for a diamond to a specific standard?

We don't keep a fixed inventory online. We source each diamond for the client, from the whole market, so tell us the standard you want, plus shape, size and budget, and we'll show you real stones with their reports. The consultation is free, by appointment or by video call. Prefer to talk first? Call (213) 261-4330.

Book a Free Consultation

Cart

No more products available for purchase