All grading standards
GCAL 8X, GIA Excellent, AGS Ideal and Hearts & Arrows, side by side.
Read moreGCAL 8X is a cut grade from GCAL, an independent diamond lab in New York. A diamond earns it only when all eight measures of its cut grade Excellent. Here's what the eight are, how 8X compares with a GIA Excellent cut, and how to get a GCAL 8X diamond through us.
Not with a filter. We don't list a fixed inventory online: we source each diamond for the client from across the market, and GCAL 8X stones are a small slice of that market. GCAL says fewer than 1% of diamonds qualify. A filter on our site would show you a handful of stones. Asking us gets you the 8X stones that fit your shape, size and budget.
Rather not fill in a form? Call (213) 261-4330 and ask for GCAL 8X.
Dan Moran's tour of the GCAL lab with its president, Angelo Palmieri. About the interview
GCAL grades each of the eight separately. If any one comes back Very Good instead of Excellent, the diamond is not 8X. GCAL introduced the grade for round diamonds in April 2021.
| Criterion | What it checks |
|---|---|
| 1. Polish | The finish of each facet's surface. |
| 2. External symmetry | How precisely the facets are shaped, placed and aligned. |
| 3. Proportions | The angles and percentages that set how light travels through the stone. |
| 4. Optical brilliance | How much white light the diamond returns to your eye. |
| 5. Fire | The flashes of colour as light splits inside the stone. |
| 6. Scintillation | The sparkle you see as the diamond, or you, move. |
| 7. Optical symmetry | How evenly the light pattern is spread across the stone. |
| 8. Hearts & Arrows (rounds) or shape aesthetics (fancy shapes) | For a round, the Hearts & Arrows pattern. For other shapes, how well the outline and look suit the shape. |
Criteria as published by GCAL and reported by National Jeweler (2021 round launch; 2022 and 2026 fancy-shape launches).
GCAL started with rounds and has added fancy shapes since. As of November 2026, its 8X site lists seven shapes:
Round (2021), oval and princess (2022), pear and marquise (December 2024), radiant, and the elongated cushion (May 2026). GCAL lists emerald as coming soon.
If you love a shape that isn't on the list, we'll show you how to judge its cut by eye and by its measurements. Compare the diamond shapes.
GCAL grades both, and both can earn 8X. The eight criteria are the same.
Dan's view: "For consumers looking for the strictest standards in lab grown diamond grading I recommend GCAL."
GIA, the largest and best-known lab, gives a cut grade to round diamonds only, on a five-step scale from Excellent to Poor. Diamonds with Excellent cut, polish and symmetry are known in the trade as "triple excellent".
GCAL 8X sets a narrower bar. By GCAL's own figures, more than half of round diamonds receive an Excellent cut grade, and fewer than 1% of those qualify for 8X. 8X also reports on optical performance (brilliance, fire, scintillation, optical symmetry) as separate grades, and it covers fancy shapes that GIA doesn't cut-grade at all.
That doesn't make every GIA Excellent stone a lesser diamond. GIA is still the reference for colour and clarity grading. The question is how much proof of cut you want, and whether you can see the difference. We'll put both in front of you so you can judge.
"I would encourage you to examine a few GIA XXX stones next to, for example, a GCAL 8x, and see how much of a difference you can actually see with your eyes."
An 8X diamond carries a laser inscription on its girdle with its GCAL report number and the 8X mark. The report shows images of the actual stone and of its light performance, and you can look up any report on GCAL's website.
GCAL also guarantees the four C's on its reports, to the consumer. As GCAL's president explains in our interview: if an appraiser disputes a grade, the stone goes back through a blind resubmission, and if GCAL got it wrong it pays the difference in retail dollars. Ask us for the current terms before you buy.
Match the number inscribed on the girdle to the report, and look the report up on GCAL's site. Ask us and we'll show you how.
"The highest cut standard in the industry, natural or lab, is the GCAL 8X. Look for a stone with that certification and you're guaranteed maximum sparkle for that shape."
"GCAL has set the highest independent grading standard in the industry ... Personally, I prefer to have a third party verification rather than trusting any vendor to grade their own homework."
"I work with GCAL stones all the time. GCAL 8X represents the most strict independent grading of any diamond, natural or lab, in the industry."
"GCAL is a truly independent lab ... so when they vouch for a stone, they have no commercial interest in the outcome."
Our relationship with GCAL: GCAL lists Concierge Diamonds as a featured retailer on its 8X website, and Dan has toured its New York lab. We also sell diamonds graded by GIA, IGI and other labs, and we'll tell you which report suits the stone you want. Read more of Dan's answers on certification.
If cut is your priority and you want independent proof of it, yes. 8X diamonds usually cost more than comparable stones because so few qualify. If you can't see the difference between an 8X and a well-cut GIA Excellent stone side by side, the extra money may be better spent on size or colour. We'll show you both.
Yes. GCAL grades natural and lab-grown diamonds to the same eight criteria.
It is a stricter cut standard. GIA Excellent is a single cut grade for rounds; 8X requires Excellent on eight separate measures, including optical ones, and also covers fancy shapes. GIA remains the reference for colour and clarity.
Yes. As of November 2026 GCAL's 8X covers round, oval, princess, pear, marquise, radiant and elongated cushion diamonds, with emerald listed as coming soon.
Look up the report number on GCAL's website and match it to the number laser-inscribed on the diamond's girdle.
Each standard measures something different. Read the next guide, or start with the Four C's.
GCAL 8X, GIA Excellent, AGS Ideal and Hearts & Arrows, side by side.
Read moreWe don't keep a fixed inventory online. We source each diamond for the client, from the whole market, so tell us the standard you want, plus shape, size and budget, and we'll show you real stones with their reports. The consultation is free, by appointment or by video call. Prefer to talk first? Call (213) 261-4330.