This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.
← The Four C's of Diamonds

Diamond Grading Standards: GCAL 8X, GIA Triple Excellent and More

The Four C's tell you what a diamond is. Grading standards tell you how well it was cut, and who says so. If you already know you want a GCAL 8X, a GIA triple excellent or a hearts and arrows diamond, here's what each one certifies, and how we find one for you.

  • Strictest cut grade

GCAL 8X

Excellent on all eight measures of cut, including brilliance, fire and scintillation. Rounds and six fancy shapes, natural or lab-grown.

Read about GCAL 8X
  • Most common benchmark

GIA triple excellent

Excellent cut, polish and symmetry from GIA. Round diamonds only, and changed for lab-grown in 2025.

Read about triple excellent
  • Symmetry pattern

Hearts & Arrows

A pattern that shows precise symmetry in a round diamond. A good sign, not a grade, and often used as a brand.

Read about hearts and arrows
  • GIA, GCAL, IGI

Grading labs compared

Same words, different standards. Which lab's report to look for on a natural or a lab-grown diamond.

Compare the labs
  • Video

Inside the GCAL lab

Dan Moran tours GCAL's New York lab with its president, Angelo Palmieri, then takes questions.

Watch the interview
  • The basics

The Four C's

Cut, colour, clarity and carat: what each means and where to spend.

Read the Four C's

The standards side by side

What each standard certifies, who issues it, and which diamonds it covers. Details and sources are on each page.

StandardIssued byWhat it certifiesShapes
GCAL 8XGCAL by SarineExcellent on all eight: polish, external symmetry, proportions, optical brilliance, fire, scintillation, optical symmetry, and Hearts & Arrows (rounds) or shape aesthetics. Natural and lab-grown.Round, oval, princess, pear, marquise, radiant, elongated cushion
GIA triple excellentGIAExcellent cut, polish and symmetry. Trade shorthand, not a GIA term.Cut grade for rounds only
GIA lab-grown PremiumGIASince October 2025: D colour, VVS or better, Excellent polish and symmetry, and Excellent cut on rounds.All; cut on rounds only
AGS IdealGIA (supplemental report)Light performance: brightness, fire and contrast. The AGS lab itself closed at the end of 2022.Rounds and some fancy shapes
Hearts & ArrowsNo single standard; one of GCAL 8X's criteria for roundsA precise optical symmetry pattern.Round
  • How it works

Can you find me a diamond to a specific standard?

Yes. We don't list a fixed inventory online, so there's no filter to click. We source each diamond for the client from across the market. Tell us the standard you want (GCAL 8X, GIA triple excellent, or anything else), plus shape, size, budget and natural or lab-grown, and we'll come back with real stones and their lab reports for you to compare.

Rather not fill in a form? Call (213) 261-4330.

Where our experience comes from

Dan Moran answers diamond questions on Reddit as u/diamonddealer, and has done for over a decade. Read his answers.

He toured GCAL's New York lab with its president in December 2024, and GCAL lists Concierge Diamonds as a featured retailer on its 8X website.

Looking for a diamond to a specific standard?

We don't keep a fixed inventory online. We source each diamond for the client, from the whole market, so tell us the standard you want, plus shape, size and budget, and we'll show you real stones with their reports. The consultation is free, by appointment or by video call. Prefer to talk first? Call (213) 261-4330.

Book a Free Consultation

Cart

No more products available for purchase