All grading standards
GCAL 8X, GIA Excellent, AGS Ideal and Hearts & Arrows, side by side.
Read more"Triple excellent" (also written 3EX or XXX) is trade shorthand for a round diamond that GIA grades Excellent for cut, polish and symmetry. It's the most common benchmark for a well-cut diamond. Here's what GIA measures, where the grade stops, and how it changed for lab-grown diamonds in 2025.
GIA has put a cut grade on round brilliant diamonds since January 2006, after 15 years of research. The scale has five steps: Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair and Poor.
The grade weighs seven things in three groups:
Polish and symmetry also get their own grades on the report. When all three say Excellent, the trade calls it triple excellent. GIA itself doesn't use the phrase; its reports just list the three grades.
Triple excellent is a floor, not a finish line. Many diamonds earn it, and they don't all look the same. Proportions inside the Excellent range still change how a stone looks.
For a round, we look for a table between 54% and 60% and a depth between 58% and 62%. More in our cut guide.
GIA gives an overall cut grade to round diamonds only. Ovals, pears, cushions, emeralds and other fancy shapes get polish and symmetry grades, but no cut grade. So a "triple excellent oval" can only mean Excellent polish and symmetry, which says nothing about how well the stone performs.
For fancy shapes, judge cut by eye and by the stone's measurements, or look for a lab that does grade fancy cuts. GCAL 8X covers ovals, pears, princesses, marquises, radiants and elongated cushions.
"GIA doesn't assign cut grades for any shape other than round, so there's no such thing as an "excellent cut pear," at least on paper. The idea is right, though. Cut is by far your most important consideration here."
Since October 1, 2025, GIA no longer gives lab-grown diamonds the usual colour, clarity and cut grades. Its Laboratory-Grown Diamond Quality Assessment describes a stone as Premium or Standard instead, and a stone below Standard gets no GIA assessment. A lab-grown diamond with a GIA report from before that date may still show 4C grades.
| GIA term | Colour | Clarity | Polish and symmetry |
|---|---|---|---|
| Premium | D | VVS or better | Excellent |
| Standard (minimum) | E to J | VS | Very Good (Good for fancy shapes) |
Source: GIA announcements of June and October 2025. For lab-grown, a GIA "Premium" round is the closest thing to triple excellent. If you want a lab-grown diamond graded in detail, GCAL still grades lab-grown on the full scale.
GCAL's 8X grade asks for Excellent on eight separate measures, including optical ones (brilliance, fire, scintillation, optical symmetry) and the Hearts & Arrows pattern for rounds. By GCAL's own figures, fewer than 1% of round diamonds that get an Excellent cut grade qualify.
GIA is still the reference for colour and clarity. For cut, the question is how much proof you want, and whether you can see the difference.
"GIA maintains the strictest standards on color and clarity grading, and their assessment is considered definitive. As for the fine details of cut, I would encourage you to examine a few GIA XXX stones next to, for example, a GCAL 8x, and see how much of a difference you can actually see with your eyes. It might not be as big a deal as you think!"
Not exactly. GIA's top cut grade is Excellent; "ideal" was the top grade at AGS, whose lab closed at the end of 2022, and many retailers use "ideal" as a brand name. Look at the lab and the grade on the report, not the label.
Not in GIA's terms. GIA grades cut for round diamonds only, so a fancy shape can have Excellent polish and symmetry but no cut grade.
Since October 1, 2025, GIA describes lab-grown diamonds as Premium or Standard instead of giving 4C grades. A Premium round needs Excellent cut, polish and symmetry, D colour and VVS clarity or better.
No. The Excellent range is broad, and proportions within it change how a diamond looks. That's why we compare stones side by side, and why stricter standards such as GCAL 8X exist.
Each standard measures something different. Read the next guide, or start with the Four C's.
GCAL 8X, GIA Excellent, AGS Ideal and Hearts & Arrows, side by side.
Read moreWe don't keep a fixed inventory online. We source each diamond for the client, from the whole market, so tell us the standard you want, plus shape, size and budget, and we'll show you real stones with their reports. The consultation is free, by appointment or by video call. Prefer to talk first? Call (213) 261-4330.