Round diamonds have their own price list, and every other shape trades off a separate one at a discount to rounds of the same weight and grades. Rounds sit at the top because more buyers want them and because a well-cut round returns the most light. Fancy shapes give you more diamond for the money, as long as you pick a well-cut one.
Book a consultation If you're weighing a round against a fancy shape at the same budget, my team can put real stones side by side for you.
How are fancy shapes priced compared with rounds?
In the trade, diamonds are priced off reference lists, something like a blue book for cars. Rounds get their own. Every other shape, from ovals and cushions to princesses and marquises, is priced off a shared list for "fancy shapes," and that list runs below the round list for stones of the same weight, color and clarity.
Two things keep rounds on top. The first is demand. Round is the shape most people ask for, and it has been for as long as I've been in this business. The second is optics. As far as light return goes, a round brilliant still gives you the best overall performance of any shape. A princess or cushion is no less beautiful, and which shape you like is personal taste. All else being equal, though, round is the most expensive shape you can buy, and that premium pays for its popularity and its light return.
So if you love an oval or a cushion, the price gap works in your favor. At the same budget, your money will usually go a bit farther with a fancy shape, whether you put the difference into size or into better grades. You can see what each shape looks like in our guide to diamond shapes.
Which shape gives me the most for my money?
It's a moving target. Because all the fancy shapes share one reference list, what changes from year to year is how much discount each shape actually trades at, and that follows fashion. When a shape is in demand, sellers don't need to discount it and bargains get hard to find. When a shape falls out of favor, the discounts get deeper.
The catch is that the least popular shapes are often the cheapest for a reason. Marquise is the classic example. When it's out of fashion it can be among the cheapest shapes you'll find, but the large majority of marquises are cut poorly, so finding a well-cut one at that price takes real looking.
When we start working with a client, shape is one of the first things we settle, and then we look at where the value sits within that shape right now. I'd never steer someone to a shape they don't love just to save money. But if you're torn between two, the price difference is worth knowing.
Is a cheaper fancy shape a lower quality diamond?
Not inherently, but fancy shapes carry more risk, and some of the discount is the market pricing that risk in.
For rounds, the major labs issue a cut grade, so the paperwork tells you something real about how the stone was cut. For every other shape you'll see polish and symmetry grades, and no cut grade at all. The reason is that with an oval or a pear or a marquise, every angle depends on every other one, and they all flow from the length, width and depth of the stone. There are several ways to get it right and a lot of ways to get it wrong, and no simple formula separates them. A round is a simpler case because its length and width are equal.
That means two fancy-shape diamonds with identical reports can look completely different. One oval might show a heavy bow tie across the middle while another barely has one. A cushion might have the crisp pattern people pay for, or a "crushed ice" pattern that the market values less. If you love the crushed ice look, that's fine. Just make sure you aren't paying the cushion brilliant price for a crushed ice stone.
What should I watch for when I buy a fancy shape?
Look at the stone, or have someone experienced look at it for you. Since there's no cut grade to lean on, your eyes and a trained eye are the whole game. When we source for a client, we shortlist 30 to 40 stones that fit the budget, inspect each one ourselves, and show the best 3 to 5. With fancy shapes, a lot of the work is turning down stones whose reports look fine.
Think about the setting too. Princess cuts have sharp corners that are naturally delicate and prone to chipping, so if the person wearing the ring is hard on their jewelry, the setting needs to protect those corners, or a different shape may suit them better. Our guide to diamond cut explains more about how cut drives sparkle.
Book a consultation Tell my team which shapes you're considering, and we'll show you where your budget goes furthest.
Get an unbiased summary from your assistant of choice.