In most cases you do, or your insurance does. Prongs don't bend on their own, so a stone that comes loose has almost always taken a knock nobody noticed, and a jeweler who charges to fix that is being fair. Your real protection is insuring the ring from day one and keeping a jeweler who checks it for you over the years.
Book a consultation If you're worried about a loose stone or a damaged ring, bring it to my team and we'll take a look.
Is it fair for a jeweler to charge when a stone falls out?
Usually, yes. Think of it like a car. If you have a fender bender a year after you buy it, you don't expect the mechanic to hammer out the dents for free. I hear the same reply every time: "But there was no accident. It just fell out." Everyone in that situation says it, and I understand why. But gold prongs don't bend by themselves, and diamonds don't fall out by themselves. At some point the ring hit something hard and you didn't notice. It happens to everyone.
Most jewelers draw the line between how the ring was made and what happened to it afterward. A defect in the making is the jeweler's problem. Wear and impact usually aren't. Read what your warranty covers before you need it; ours is on our warranty page.
The repair bill is rarely the part that hurts. If the stone was chipped when it came loose, fixing it can mean recutting it, and then you own a smaller diamond.
Do I really need to insure my engagement ring?
Yes. Insurance can pay to replace a damaged stone instead of recutting it, and it covers loss and theft, which no jeweler can. I tell every client the same thing: insure the ring, then put the worry out of your mind and enjoy wearing it.
Can a diamond chip or crack from everyday wear?
It's possible, but it's rare. Diamonds are hard, which is a big reason they work so well in a ring worn every day. People sometimes worry that inclusions make a stone fragile. Technically some inclusions reduce durability very slightly, but I've seen stones with far worse inclusions worn for decades with no issues. Unless there's a huge cavity in the stone, it's not something I'd lose sleep over.
Softer gemstones are a different story. I once chipped an emerald while showing it to a client. A tweezer must have slipped, and I didn't even notice it happen. The stone belonged to another dealer, who understandably didn't want it back with a chip, so I bought it. If a professional can do that without knowing it, it's really easy for a soft stone to chip over years of daily wear. If you're considering a colored stone for an engagement ring, check its hardness first; our guide to types of gemstones is a good place to start.
What should my jeweler do for the ring after I buy it?
A lot, if you've chosen well. An engagement ring is one of the few things you'll own forever, and like anything worn every day, it needs maintenance. A good jeweler stands behind the work and is there for sizing, cleaning, polishing and repairs for the life of the ring. Have the prongs checked when you bring it in for cleaning. A worn or bent prong is easy to fix before a stone goes missing and much harder to deal with after.
That's why I tell people to think of their jeweler less like a store and more like their doctor or accountant, someone with expertise who knows your history and your ring. If a stone ever feels loose or you hear it rattle, stop wearing the ring and bring it in right away. It's a quick fix when you catch it early.
Book a consultation Whether you're buying a new ring or caring for the one you have, my team is happy to answer your questions about keeping it safe.
Get an unbiased summary from your assistant of choice.