This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Why can two diamonds with the same grades look different?

A grading report records a handful of measurements, and plenty of what you actually see in a diamond falls outside them. Two stones with identical color, clarity and cut grades can differ in the tint behind the color grade, in where the inclusions sit, and in how much haze or fluorescence dulls the sparkle. You only catch those differences by looking at the stones themselves.

Book a consultation Bring us the two stones that look identical on paper, and my team will tell you which one actually looks better.

What doesn't a grading report tell you?

I like to compare buying a diamond off its paperwork to marrying someone off their high school transcript. The transcript tells you something real about the person. It just doesn't tell you enough to make the decision.

Color is a good example. A color grade measures how much color a stone has, but not the shade of that color. Within the same grade, one stone might have a yellow overtone and another a brown or gray one. The report reads the same for both, and they won't look the same in a ring, especially set in white gold or platinum.

I could show you two diamonds that look very similar on paper and completely different in person. It happens all the time. If you want a refresher on what each grade measures, our guide to the Four Cs covers the basics.

Do two diamonds with the same clarity grade look the same?

No. Not every VS2 is created equal, and not every SI1 is either. Clarity grades describe how many inclusions a stone has and how big they are, and that leaves out a lot of what matters to your eye.

Location is the big one. A dark crystal sitting right under the table, in the middle of the stone, can be visible to the naked eye. The same inclusion out near the edge, where a prong might cover it, can disappear completely, and both stones can carry the same grade.

Then there are clouds. Every now and then you'll see a comment at the bottom of a report saying the clarity grade is based on clouds that aren't shown. In a lower clarity stone, that usually means there's no single inclusion to point at. Instead, a fine haze of tiny pinpoints runs through the whole diamond and makes it look milky. You won't see a flaw as such, but the stone won't shine the way it should. As I've told buyers before, you might not notice until you see it next to one that shines properly, "but once you see it, you'll never unsee it."

Our clarity guide explains the grade itself, but only looking at a particular stone will tell you whether it's eye clean.

Why would a well-graded diamond look dull?

Fluorescence is a common culprit. Many diamonds glow under ultraviolet light, and in many of them it does no harm. But strong fluorescence, especially in a high color stone, can affect a diamond's luster and make it look hazy or oily. There's a reason fluorescence affects the price as much as it does. A fluorescent stone can be fine, but I wouldn't buy one without someone experienced looking at it first, because the report only tells you the strength of the glow, and it says nothing about what that glow does to the stone's appearance.

Cut is the other one. With rounds, a cut grade is fairly useful. With every other shape, the labs don't issue a cut grade at all, because the proportions depend on each other in ways no chart can capture. Two ovals with the same paperwork can perform very differently.

So how should I compare diamonds?

Look at them, side by side, in more than one kind of light. You would be amazed how different two stones with identical grading can look in person. Once you've seen a few next to each other, you'll learn very quickly what you care about and what you don't, and that's often different from what you expected going in.

Be wary of anything that promises to reduce a diamond to a chart or a single number. There's just too much going on in a stone for that. Sometimes a diamond is a "you know it when you see it" situation, and no report gives you that feeling. If two stones look the same to you, a decimal point on paper shouldn't decide it.

This is also where an experienced dealer earns their keep. When we source a stone for a client, we pull a shortlist of 30 to 40 diamonds that fit the budget, inspect each one ourselves, and show the client the best 3 to 5. Most of the stones we turn down have perfectly respectable reports. They just don't look as good as their paperwork says. If you can't come to our showroom, we can do the whole process remotely, with photos and video of each stone, and the consultation costs nothing extra.

Book a consultation If you're comparing diamonds that look the same on paper, send them to my team and we'll tell you what the reports leave out.

Ask AI about this question

Get an unbiased summary from your assistant of choice.

Cart

No more products available for purchase