This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Are natural diamonds actually rare, and does it matter?

Yes. Jewelry-quality natural diamonds over a carat are genuinely rare, and the story about warehouses of stones held back to keep prices high is decades out of date. Rarity matters because nobody can make more natural diamonds, so a natural stone keeps a real resale value, but it doesn't guarantee the price will only go up.

Book a consultation Bring this question to my team and we'll show you what rarity looks like in the stones that fit your budget.

Why do people say diamonds aren't rare?

Because they are quoting the wrong numbers. When someone tells you diamonds are common, they are usually citing the total weight of every diamond mined. That figure includes tiny stones and huge amounts of low-quality material that goes into saw blades and drill bits. Those diamonds really are plentiful, and none of them will ever be set in an engagement ring.

Narrow it down to what you would actually buy: a stone over a carat, white enough and clean enough to look beautiful in a ring. That is a very small slice of what comes out of the ground. Relative to the number of people who want one, it is not easy to come by at all.

Isn't the supply held back on purpose?

That used to be true, a long time ago. I know people at the large mining companies, and they will tell you flatly that there are no hidden warehouses full of diamonds anymore. The stockpiling era ended more than thirty years ago.

Natural diamonds come from a limited number of mines, and nobody can make more of them. One of the world's biggest mines, in Australia, closed in 2020 because it had run out of material, and other large mines are getting closer to the end of their lives.

New mines won't fill the gap quickly. Opening one costs an enormous amount, often including building a whole town around the site, and major new finds have been scarce for years. Meanwhile, a growing middle class in countries like China and India has a real appetite for diamonds, so more people are chasing fewer good stones.

Does rarity mean natural diamond prices only go up?

No, and I would be wary of anyone who tells you they do. Prices for natural diamonds move with demand, and they have gone down as well as up. I don't have a crystal ball, and neither does anyone else.

What rarity gives you is a floor. Because the supply is limited, a natural diamond behaves more like gold than like a television, and there is always a buyer for it. That buyer won't necessarily pay what you paid, but the stone keeps a real value as the years go by. A lab-grown diamond doesn't have that floor, because there is no limit on how many can be made.

Rarity only protects you if you buy well, though. Pay a big retail-brand markup and the stone may take many years to catch up to what you spent. Our guide to the resale value of a diamond goes into what drives that number.

Should rarity decide between natural and lab-grown?

Only if it matters to you. I work with both natural and lab-grown diamonds every day, and I think they both have a place. They aren't the same thing, though. An expert can tell them apart, and they come with very different value propositions.

For some people, rarity is the whole point. They love that the stone was formed deep underground over a billion years or more, and that nothing like it exists anywhere else. For others, that story means little and they would rather put the budget into size. Both are good choices once you know the difference. My only ask is that you make the decision with your eyes open. If you want to compare the two, our guide all about lab-made diamonds is a good place to start.

Book a consultation Tell my team whether rarity matters to you, and we'll shortlist natural and lab-grown stones to match.

Ask AI about this question

Get an unbiased summary from your assistant of choice.

Cart

No more products available for purchase