Yes. GIA grades color and clarity more strictly than IGI, so the same letters on an IGI report usually describe a softer stone, and the market prices IGI stones lower for that reason. An IGI diamond can still be a good buy, as long as you pay an IGI price for it and someone you trust has looked at the actual stone.
Book a consultation Bring the report you're weighing to my team and we'll tell you what the stone behind it is really like.
Why would the same diamond get different grades at GIA and IGI?
Every reputable lab sets its own standards for color, clarity and cut. GIA is widely treated as the gold standard, and it holds the strictest line on color and clarity. In the trade, its assessment is considered definitive. That doesn't make GIA perfect, but it is the benchmark everyone else gets measured against.
IGI's grading is looser, and in my experience less consistent. I work with GIA and IGI stones every day. I have seen the same diamond come out three grades apart between the two labs, and I have seen plenty where the grades were close. You can't know which kind you're looking at from the report alone.
How do I know IGI grades softer?
The clearest evidence is the market itself. When a dealer has a stone graded, they choose the lab. A GIA report sells for more, all else being equal. If the dealer believed a stone would get the same grades at GIA, sending it to IGI would be leaving money on the table. So when a natural diamond arrives with an IGI report, it is fair to assume the owner expected GIA to grade it lower.
Some dealers have built a business on this gap. They buy GIA-graded stones, resubmit them to IGI for better letters, and resell them to buyers who think the two labs are interchangeable.
Is an IGI report a red flag?
No. A lab with a softer standard can still be useful. The problem comes when a softer grade is priced like a strict one. As a rough example, a GIA H SI1 and an IGI G VS2 might look about the same in person, so they should cost about the same too. Once a stone is priced for what it actually is, the report becomes more a matter of branding than of value.
So if you're buying an IGI stone, make sure you're paying the IGI price for it. Don't pay a GIA price for IGI paper. The one case where I'd tell you to stick with GIA, full stop, is when you're buying a stone sight unseen with nobody you trust to look at it for you. Then the stricter report is the best protection you have.
Does this change for lab-grown diamonds?
If you're shopping lab-grown, you'll see a lot of IGI reports. A big reason is cost: IGI's lab-grown reports are much cheaper than GIA's, and for a stone that sells for relatively little, a pricey report is hard to justify. GIA said in 2025 that its lab-grown reports would carry less detail, which pushes even more of that market toward IGI.
Lab-grown stones come out of production in different quality tiers, and in my experience the lower tiers tend to end up with IGI reports. You might get a lovely stone with an IGI report, or you might not. You need someone to look at it to be sure.
What should I actually trust, the lab or the stone?
The stone. A report is a useful summary, but it leaves out a lot of what makes a diamond beautiful, like how light moves through it and whether it shows a dark bow tie. Two stones with identical paper can look completely different on a hand. You can read more about what each grade means in our guide to the four Cs of diamonds.
That's why we shortlist 30 to 40 stones for every client, inspect them ourselves, and show only the best three to five. If you can't come to the showroom, we send high-resolution photos and video of each stone, so you can judge the diamond itself before you decide.
Book a consultation Send my team the GIA or IGI stones on your list and we'll help you compare them fairly.
Get an unbiased summary from your assistant of choice.