This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Should I choose moissanite or a sapphire instead of a diamond?

If you want something that looks like a diamond, I'd steer you away from moissanite: it's made to imitate a diamond, and it will always be judged on how well it does that. If you want a different stone on its own terms, sapphire is one of the few that holds up to daily wear, and it has a long history in engagement rings. A smaller diamond, or a lab-grown one, is the better answer when what you really want is a diamond for less money.

Book a consultation If you're weighing a diamond against something else, talk it through with my team before you decide.

Why don't you recommend moissanite?

I'll be upfront that I'm in the diamond business, so weigh my view with that in mind. Moissanite is a real material. My objection is about its purpose: it was designed as a diamond simulant, so the trade and the public both judge it by how closely it resembles a diamond.

Think of an Elvis impersonator contest. Nobody is looking for the best singer. They're looking for whoever sounds most like Elvis, and any difference counts against you. Moissanite is in the same position. To a knowledgeable eye it doesn't look the same as a diamond, and nothing replicates the look of a diamond as well as a diamond does.

That leaves the wearer with a stone that comes with an asterisk. Either you hope nobody notices, or you explain the choice again and again. Some couples are fine with that, and that's their call. I'd just rather you go in knowing it. Get a diamond, or get something else, but don't get a diamond with an asterisk.

Is a sapphire durable enough for an engagement ring?

Yes, and that's the main reason I'd point you to sapphire over most colored stones. An engagement ring gets worn every day for decades, so hardness matters as much as color. On the Mohs hardness scale, sapphire is almost as hard as diamond and will stand up to years of wear.

Plenty of other popular stones won't. Tanzanite, for example, is also blue and looks somewhat similar, but it's much more fragile and far more likely to chip or crack. If you go with a colored stone, think about how it will survive real life as well as how it looks on day one. Our guide to types of gemstones covers the options.

Sapphire also isn't only blue. It comes in a range of colors, so if you love green or pink, there may be a sapphire that gives you the color with the durability.

Is a sapphire actually cheaper than a diamond?

It depends entirely on the stone. People often assume colored stones are the budget choice, but a high-quality natural sapphire can cost as much as a diamond, or more. Many collectors and wealthy buyers treat fine sapphires, rubies and emeralds as status pieces in their own right.

Plenty of couples get engaged with sapphires, and some of the most famous engagement rings in the world are sapphires. Lab-grown sapphires have been around for a long time, and natural sapphires have kept a market of their own. So I'd pick a sapphire because you love sapphires, and price it as a precious stone, without assuming it's the cheap option.

What if I really want a diamond, but the budget is tight?

Then I'd stay within the budget that makes you comfortable and get a diamond. Maybe it's a bit smaller than you pictured, or not top quality on paper, but it's a diamond with no explanation attached. A lab-grown diamond is also a real diamond, with the same look and hardness, at a lower price. Our article all about lab-made diamonds explains how they compare with natural stones.

Another route if money is tight right now: put a temporary stone, such as a white sapphire, in the setting your partner loves, and replace it with a diamond later as the budget allows. You can also start with a diamond in a simple solitaire and upgrade the setting down the road.

Whichever way you go, it's your decision to make. I work with natural and lab-grown diamonds and with colored stones, and our budgets run from under $2,000 to about $1,000,000. The consultation costs nothing extra, so there's no downside to comparing a few real stones side by side before you commit.

Book a consultation Tell my team what you're drawn to and what you want to spend, and we'll show you diamonds and sapphires that fit.

Ask AI about this question

Get an unbiased summary from your assistant of choice.

Cart

No more products available for purchase