This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Does a custom engagement ring cost more than a ready-made one?

Usually not. A custom engagement ring generally costs about the same as a comparable ring from a store's case, and often less, because you pay only for the design and stones you want and none of the cost of a ring that sat in inventory. Most of the money in an engagement ring is in the center diamond anyway, so the setting is rarely the part that breaks a budget.

Book a consultation Bring us a ring you've seen in a store, and we'll show you what it would take to make it for your stone and your budget.

Why would a custom ring cost less than one already in the case?

People hear "custom" and assume "expensive." I understand the instinct, but look at what you're paying for when you buy off the shelf. The price of a finished ring already includes the time of the jeweler who made it, so you pay for labor either way.

Then there's the cost of the ring sitting there. A jeweler who stocks a case full of finished rings has put money into them. While a ring waits for a buyer, that money isn't earning anything, and if the jeweler borrowed to buy the stock, the interest keeps running. Money costs money, and that cost ends up in the price tag. A custom ring is made when you order it, so you don't carry anyone's inventory.

You also stop paying for features you don't care about. With a finished ring, you take the closest match you can find and pay for everything that comes with it. With custom, the details on the ring are the ones you asked for.

Where does the money in an engagement ring actually go?

Into the center stone, by a wide margin. In a ring with a substantial diamond, the setting is a small share of the total. That's why I like to choose the stone first and build the ring around it. Get the diamond right and you've made the decision that matters most to both the look and the price. If you're still working out what to prioritize in a stone, our guide to the four Cs is a good place to start.

It's also why we build engagement rings to order instead of filling cases with them. When we start with your diamond, we can shortlist 30 to 40 stones that fit your budget, inspect them ourselves and show you the best 3 to 5, then design the setting to suit the one you choose.

What do I get from custom that a store ring can't give me?

A ring that matches itself. When a halo or side-stone setting is made separately from the center, the small diamonds often don't match the center stone in color or appearance. The ring ends up looking like it was assembled from parts, and once you notice it, you can't stop seeing it. When we make the setting for a specific stone, we pick the accent diamonds to match it, and we make the ring in your partner's finger size and preferred metal from the start, so nothing has to be cut and soldered later.

The way the ring is built matters too. Many mass-produced rings are cast with the small stones set in the mold all at once, instead of one at a time by hand. That's cheaper to make, but those settings don't hold up as well. Heat one up to resize it or set a new stone, and the other stones can loosen and start to fall out. A handmade ring from someone you can go back to, the person who actually made it, is a better long-term bet.

Is there any downside to going custom?

Time is the real one. Most of our custom rings take 4 to 8 weeks from design approval, so impulse shopping isn't an option. If you have a proposal date in mind, get in touch 60 to 90 days ahead and you'll have room to choose the stone and the design without rushing either.

The other is that you have to trust the person making it. There's an old saying in the trade: "If you don't know jewelry, know your jeweler." Custom work rewards a good relationship with whoever is building your ring. If you want to see how our process runs from first conversation to delivery, read the custom ring design experience.

Budget isn't the obstacle most people think it is. We make rings for budgets from under $2,000 to about $1,000,000, and the consultation costs nothing extra: you pay only for the ring.

Book a consultation Tell my team what you have in mind and what you want to spend, and we'll price it as a custom piece so you can compare for yourself.

Ask AI about this question

Get an unbiased summary from your assistant of choice.

Cart

No more products available for purchase